Idols and Icons: Why Murti Should Be Used Instead

Representational Forms in Religious Worship

 

Most of the religions and spiritual traditions of the world – with the general exception of Protestant Christians, Muslims and Jews – use images, representational forms or statues in their worship.

 

Roman Catholic and Greek Orthodox churches abound with statues, paintings and pictures of various types. Hindu, Buddhist, Jain, Taoist and Shinto groups use them extensively both in temples and home shrines. Sikhs prominently display pictures of their gurus. Native American, African and Asian religions use images and deity forms as part of their communities and traditional ways of life. The ancient religions of the world from Mexico to Greece, Rome, Egypt, Babylonia, India and China used images prominently, as archeology clearly reveals.

 

The use of images is an integral part of human religious practices and no universal or all-inclusive religion or spirituality can be regarded as complete without them. Even many Protestant Christians have pictures of Jesus in their house or church, or at least a symbolic cross. Muslims often have pictures of their religious or political leaders, with religious depictions of Ali or Hussein used commonly among Shiites.

 


Idols or Icons

 

However, there is a strange and hypocritical dichotomy in how religious images are denoted. When they are part of the Christian tradition they are called “icons” and classified as works of “religious art” that are regarded as sacred in nature. When they are part of non-Christian and pagan traditions they are demeaned as “idols,” which is a derogatory term that indicates not the sacred but mere superstition. In the case of Native American and African images, even when done by a culture as advanced as the Mayas of Central America – which built great pyramids and had many great cities – they are lumped along with so-called “primitive art”, fetishes or totems. Sacred images of traditional cultures throughout the world, including India, are often regarded as mere “folk art”.

 

An image of Christ as the good shepherd is called an icon and viewed with respect. An image of Krishna as the good cow herder – another image of the Divine watching over the souls of men – is called an idol, which encourages one to look down upon it. This is prejudice and negative stereotyping of the worst order.

 

What Christian would accept calling a depiction of Christ an idol? Would Christian religious leaders approve of it in the press of Christian countries? What Christians in India would accept it?

 


Denigration of Hinduism as Idolatry

 

Unfortunately, Hindus routinely accept that depictions of their deities – who represent powers of universal consciousness and Self-realization – are demeaned as idols. The news media of India does this commonly as does academia, which encourages the western media to continue the practice that easily fits in with their negative depiction of Hinduism according to continuing colonial and missionary distortions.

 

To call such images as idols implies that those who worship them practice idolatry or take the image itself as the deity. This adds yet more prejudice and error to the statement. The use of the term idol inflames the sentiments of anti-idolatry religions like Christianity and Islam, as both the Bible and the Koran, at least in places, instruct their followers to oppose idolaters and smash their temples and images as unholy.

 

Christians and Muslims have long been taught to try to convert idolaters, as well as to denigrate their practices as primitive, if not devil worship. Anti-idolatry wars have killed millions of people over centuries and destroyed thousands of sacred sites and sacred images of the so-called idolaters. Anti-idolatry campaigns have encouraged every sort of plunder, prejudice and genocide, and still promote discrimination against image using traditions, particularly those outside of Christianity.

 

The use of an image – whether we call it an icon or an idol – does not imply belief in the reality of the image in itself. That we keep a photograph of our spouse or children at our work desk does not mean that we think that they are the photograph. It is a reminder, not a false reality.

 


Murti, Not Idol

 

The correct term for the image in Hindu Dharma is a murti, which implies a symbolic representation of a higher reality. Such murtis require “prana pratishta” or special rituals to bring the spirit or deity temporarily into the form. In celebrations like Ganesh Chaturthi or Navaratri the images are discarded or immersed in the ocean after the celebrations are over once this purpose is achieved. Temple deities, however, are enduring, though they require daily worship to sustain the higher spiritual power flowing through them.

 

Hindu Dharma employs the largest variety of images, whether sculpture, paintings, or visualizations, along with music, dance and dramas, than any other spiritual tradition in the world. All forms are used including human, animal and plant, supernatural depictions, symbols or designs. These encompass all of nature and all types of artistic expression. This is a wonderful heritage must be honored and shared, not veiled or suppressed as idolatry.

 

The Hindu use of images is part of a yogic science of bringing down higher cosmic influences through special rituals, mantras and the offering of special substances like incense, flowers, fragrances, liquid food or special ghee lamps. Such ritualistic worship with candles and incense remains in many anti-image traditions as well.

Given the power of the media today, it is very dangerous to allow such wrong terminology to continue, particularly in the age of Islamic terrorism that feeds upon negative depictions of other religions. Using such terms as idols, the media is not fostering communication but promoting discrimination and violence. Such abuse of language should be challenged and replaced wherever it is found.

 


Campaign to Replace the Term Idol with Murti

 

Hindus should develop a campaign to replace the term “idol” with that of “murti”, which can slowly correct this distortion. Hindu thought accepts the Divine as both formless and as present in all names and forms. Its highest goal is realization of the Universal Self through Yoga and meditation, not simply promoting an exclusive belief or statement of faith. It employs images as one of its many factors of worship including symbols, mantras, yantras, pranayama, visualization, concentration, and meditation.

 

The honoring of murtis can be found among many great Hindu sages and gurus from ancient to modern times and is the basis of Hindu temple worship. Paramahansa Ramakrishna is a good example of a great guru for whom murti puja was very important. Even Adi Shankara, the great teacher of non-dualist Vedanta, also composed many wonderful hymns to Hindu deities, which include murtis and temple worship.

 

Many Hindu murtis are great works of art, and we find them in museums throughout the world. These murtis should be honored as sacred. This will also help in dealing with the stealing and selling of murtis under the guise of their being mere works of Asian art.

 

So please, dear Hindu friends, stop using the term idol and replace it with murti, explaining the meaning of the term to non-Hindus as required. It will definitely make a difference and aid in a proper understanding of Hindu Dharma, which unfortunately still remains probably the most misunderstood and maligned spiritual tradition in the world – sadly largely because of its many wonderful and beautiful images, symbols and statues.

 

This article was first published in Hindu Post

 

 

Related Articles >>

Shiva and Shakti Yogas

Yoga means unification, which is first the unity of all the dualities and contraries that constitute the energies of life. Yoga philosophy teaches us to understand and transcend duality, but this rests upon harmonizing the dualities within us in a transformative state of balance. Shiva and Shakti as the dual

Yoga & Ayurveda in an Age of Social and Economic Uncertainty

In these times of economic and social uncertainty, Yoga and Ayurveda practitioners and schools have faced numerous unpredictable challenges, and often a significant decline in their revenues. After the global shutdown following the initial Covid outbreak, many Yoga Studios had to close, and many were not able to reopen again

Ayurveda and the Mind: Keys to Yoga and Ayurveda Psychology

Ayurveda is inherently a psychological as much as a physical system of medicine. Its scope of practice includes both physical (sharirika) and mental (manasika) diseases. Therefore, we cannot really understand Ayurveda without looking at its view of the mind and consciousness. As Ayurveda holds that diseases arise more from our

Veda and Yoga are One: Veda is knowledge and Yoga is its practice

Veda is the knowledge and Yoga is its practice. It is that simple. They are two sides of the same truth. Yoga not only leads us to Veda, but also expresses it. Veda embodies itself through Yoga as its manifestation. Veda, from the root “vid” to know, refers to Knowledge

Why the practice of Yoga should begin with Ayurveda

Following Ayurveda along with Yoga  helps us gain complete harmony and balance in body and mind so that we can discover our true Self that is one with all. Most people today practice Yoga, particularly asana and pranayama, for health benefits as the primary factor, extending at times to mantra,

The Ancient Yoga of the Sun

What if the most powerful force for energizing all Yoga practices were as obvious and visible as the Sun? The fact is that it is. The Sun, properly understood not merely as an outer but as an inner energy source, reflects the supreme light of Yoga both in our own

Ayurvedic Implications of Yoga Sutras of Patanjali

We will explore the extensive relationship and vast interconnections between Yoga and Ayurveda, focusing on the Yoga Sutras. This examination extends to important issues of Yoga sadhana, Yoga therapy and Ayurvedic healing. Yoga, Ayurveda and related Vedic disciplines have more connections than usually acknowledged, particularly in the West. We cannot

Vedic Counseling and Karmic Counseling

Karmic Responsibility: Taking Control of Your Life The first thing Vedic counseling teaches us is that our lives are a product of our own actions or karma. Who we are and what we experience, both individually and collectively, is the result of forces that we have set in motion and

Mauna: The Yoga of Silence

Mauna, the Secret Limb of Yoga Mauna refers to the practice of not-speaking, and one who does this regularly is called a Muni, a sign of great respect in Hindu and yogic thought. While not-speaking is an important part of Mauna, it is much more than that. The voice is

Shakti Sadhana and Divine Grace

Shakti Sadhana by Yogini Shambhavi   All of our lives should be a Shakti Sadhana, a cultivation of the Yoga Shakti on all levels outwardly and inwardly. For this we are always supported by Mother Nature who is the very embodiment of Shakti for us. Shakti sadhana is not about

Shakti, the Yoga Sutras and Patanjali

Some scholars state that there is no mention of Shakti in the Yoga Sutras. This is incorrect. Shakti is the last word in the Yoga Sutras that sums up its entire teaching and defines its goal as the realization of the Purusha. It suggests what is referred to as Kundalini

The Shiva Linga and its Meaning

Shiva and Shakti Western scholars and some in India try to reduce the Shiva linga and Shakti yoni, the two main Tantric symbols of ascending and descending cosmic forces – which are often represented by upright conical stones for the Shiva linga and circular stones for the Shakti yoni –

Dr Frawley's Latest Course>>

The Vedic Secrets of the Nakshatras

In this special four-hour video course, Dr David Frawley examine the Nakshatras starting from their ancient Vedic roots, exploring their qualities, energies, spiritual powers and deities, including much material not available in existing texts. It will also correlate the meanings of the Nakshatras with the constellations and fixed stars.